Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-44818673-20200502124249/@comment-31549837-20200508193120

In my opinion, 20 rips or more is when a source should be in serious consideration for a channel meme. Though I understand this isn’t exactly the best way to look at things, and hasn’t been shown to work in the past. Aphex Twin meets this criteria, and Daft Punk is above 30, but are not really considered channel memes. I don’t think just bumping this number up even higher will be able to make that better. Though by 50 rips is when I think something can definitively be called a channel meme with not much debate.

Deciding what is and isn’t a meme is gonna be challenging, and I think “notability” may be the best way to look at it like Ironwestie said, though it has its own challenge as well.

Is Crank That Super Mario notable? Some might argue yes because it had an entire day mostly themed around it and has briefly shown up at other times, while others would argue no as it was primarily just an “event meme”.

I guess to end this off, I do agree that having the memes spilt up across seasons wasn’t the best move, and should probably be reverted back to how it was before.