Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-24362891-20200611141824/@comment-11562685-20200611190638

I agree with Super10ZX. Once a source has ~20 uses, it should be in consideration for meme status. However, it's always going to be debatable. Actually, over the past few days I've been thinking about suggesting a "memes for consideration" thread or subforum, entirely dedicated pointing out any highly-used source and getting a general consensus on if it should be counted as a meme or not. Because if it's always going to be debatable, we might as well have a place for debating it.

Also to add on to what Super10ZX said with cutting Elliot Rodger: I agree with this. Some info on him should moved to the list of minor CCC characters, though. I also think we should cut L.A.M.A.J and ERIOIOIRE. All the information on them can be moved to their rip and playlist pages. AMUNO should also be "cut" (not really, since he still gets an article due to being a contributor, but I mean being cut as a meme). The one meme I'd give a grandfather clause to is JustinRPG, since he has a disproportionately high amount of lore relevance, to both the Reboot and CCC.

One more thing. I want to give my thought process behind the ~20 rips bar. For me, it's mostly a matter of "what if we just listed all of the rips featuring this source instead?" when thinking about memes. Because keep in mind, every source should be listed on the list of songs featured in rips. However, splitting things up, putting them on the list of rips referencing YouTubers, the "references in other rips" section on playlist category pages, or a whole category under Category:Rips featuring..., is in the best interest of the wiki. It keeps large lists off the already unmanageably-large superlist.

In my opinion, a single source's list starts getting distractingly large when it's at ~20 uses. See List of songs featured in rips for an example of that, with 23 rips. So, I personally set the bar there. "Brain Power" should probably be moved, by the way.