Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-44818673-20200502124249/@comment-44818673-20200508200203

I'm starting to think that splitting the list into different seasons isn't really that practical either.

I think something to consider is if the joke is more often used in medley rips rather than in solo rips. This was a key reason why I removed "Bassline Junkie" from the list.

Something else to think about for a lot of the lesser used jokes is whether or not they "originated" on SiIva. Key example here is Differences. Yeah, it originated outside of the channel, but it only really became a meme here. Another good example is mf doom. Then of course you have more oftenly used things like We Are Number One and The Nutshack. Those two kind of originated as memes on SiIva if you think about it.

But I do think notability is an important factor that should come into play when classifying what a meme is, along with frequency. I might post a list of what I would consider what is and what isn't a channel meme, but it would take a while for me to come up with one.