Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-24362891-20200611141824/@comment-31549837-20200611184713

To answer the question in the opening post. 50 rips is when I say something can concretely count. Over 20 rips is when a meme should potentially be put into consideration, and anywhere from 20-49 is when it can probably be put on the wiki as a channel meme.

I used to be fairly against Crank That Super Mario getting its own page, though now I’m kinda warming up to it. May just have to be used a teeny bit more for me to say “Yeah let’s do it” (also if anyone knows the exact number of rips it has right now that would be nice).

As per the discussion from a previous thread, what should and shouldn’t be counted as a meme should revolve around a combination of frequent use and overall notability on the channel as a whole.

I guess to add stuff that has pages but I don’t feel are notable enough. I think Elliot Rodger‎ can go. He (quite understandably with current YouTube stuff) hasn’t been used in a very long time. And has been in less than 10 rips overall, with the only kinda significant thing was being indirectly implied in the CCC.

Oh yeah, and more of my minor nitpicks:
 * I’m not a fan of how some frequently ripped tracks have rips featuring categories. Wii Shop Channel‎, Slider and Gourmet Race are ok enough, but Pursuit ~ Cornered‎, Pollyanna, Ground Theme‎, Green Hill Zone, and Mt. Dedede‎ I’m a little iffy on. And especially Humoresque of a Little Dog‎ isn’t notable enough. Gadget Room I’m a little iffy on too, though I think we can keep it for now. From what I understand there were plans to give every frequently ripped track a rips featuring category, though that idea seems to have been scrapped with a few of these living as remains.
 * Veggietales (which I’d argue doesn’t need a category) is called “Rips with Veggietales” and not “Rips featuring Veggietales”. Though I understand that can simply be moved. Categories not really that big to even warrant use of the bot.

One last thing to add. I assume that by going off my own 50+ rips rule for memes, Bonetrousle might actually count towards that. We got 4 additional Touhou song categories, a second Undertale category along with Megalovania would probably be fine. Though I don’t know the exact number for sure. I’ll probably find out when I stop being lazy and finish updating the Rips featuring Undertale category. (Also gonna have to polish up the memes template and remove the music memes template. We’ll see how long that takes to get through).