Category talk:Humans

I'm supposing this category is about SiIvaGunner human characters from the lore like Chad Warden.

I don't really think Joel fits in, unless he has appeared in a video I forgot about.

Merrygoroundoflife (talk) 21:13, February 21, 2017 (UTC)
 * No Joel isn't in the SCCC (yet) but the speech in Old Times says that basically everything is either a human or a figment. But I get why you don't want it, I guess we could only apply the Human category for SCCC characters. A Fanclorn user (talk) 22:39, February 21, 2017 (UTC)

By the way, does Joel and Bob Dylan even appear once as a character? Also, do you consider that Misha's appearance on the tower one day makes him a Human character?

Merrygoroundoflife (talk) 09:27, April 15, 2017 (UTC)
 * IMO Bob Dylan is clearly worthy of the character tag since it is not really the actual Bob Dylan, just a caricature performed by PinkieOats. It's a Mr Rental / Green de la Bean situation, where the character and the meme are the same. Also he physically appeared at least once in GO MY WAY!! (M@STER Version) - THE iDOLM@STER and even have his own album. Joel is more ambiguous, but I think it is like AMUNO: a contributor who also is a meme on the channel, so yeah, not really a character after all: he doesn't interact in any "lore-induced way" with other characters. Misha however is definitely not a "character" for me, just the singer of a meme like PSY, Smash Mouth or Santana. (but if any of them ever appear in the SCCC in any other major way, then they should have their own page.)

I still don't really agree with Bob Dylan: even if he got an album, it's a really minor meme, he never appeared on the tower and he never appeared in the lore as someone important. I get how you consider that a caricature/impersonification is a character, but to me it sounds like saying pannenkoek2012 is a character from SiIvaGunner since Joel caricatured him in File Select Fusion.

I think Bob Dylan is more similar to AMUNO, because it's reallly that: videos that appear once in a while, all done by the same contributor. Just like Kazoo rips, Bowflex rips and weird AMVs.

I agree with everything else, like Misha and PSY (and the Rapper's Union members) being singers before being characters. Thanks for answering!

Merrygoroundoflife (talk) 09:18, April 17, 2017 (UTC)