Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-11562685-20190925225514

This is something I've wanted to bring up for a while, if you look at Category:Love Live! School idol festival, the "References in other rips" section is noticeably huge.

Similarly, The Beatles' section in list of songs featured in rips is pretty big as well, and I know certain rippers love making Beatles references in rips, so I have no doubt that it will keep growing.

Honestly, I'm not sure what is supposed to qualify the creation of a category, since some "Rips featuring" categories exist with barely any rips in them just because the thing is considered a meme on the channel, like, , and. On the opposite end of the spectrum there's and, , and , which don't have meme articles (aside from DDLC, but that article sparked a debate that never got resolved), and they aren't considered channel memes (are they?), but the sheer quantity of references is enough to move the list into its own category.

So, I think Love Live! could fall in with these, as a game with enough references to move the list into its own category. The Beatles would be a cross with this idea and which similarly covers multiple songs from a single source and has a list on the category page (the difference being that, mainly due to Chaze pointing out its significance, Maroon 5 is considered a channel meme, and has a meme article).

Another thing I want to bring up is an idea I'm more iffy on: would "Rips featuring Mario" be a good idea? Rips with Mario songs as the joke? There's definitely enough that it would make a sizeable category, despite no single song being used very often. If you need proof: Combining only, , and (Play a Mini-Game!) would be ~30 rips, that's already the average category size for minor memes. 