I noticed that there a few variants of the Mega Man thumbnail missing from its category page, both of them being in-video ones, so perhaps we can add these to that page:

• "Fire Man Stage": Notice how this one is a shade darker and more wider than the original GiIvaSunner version. Not sure if this counts, though.

• "Game Over" and "Guts Man Stage (OST Version)": This version of the thumbnail doesn't have the copyright notices at the bottom of the screen, and is zoomed in.

There is also one missing for Street Fighter II: The World Warrior that is used for the "Chun-Li's Theme" and "Ken's Theme (Beta Mix)" rips, again seen in-video.

have a nice day >:]

What I've seen is that some track pages for tracks like "Uwa!! So HEATS!!♫ - Undertale (Flustered Fernando)" are formatted in the style of a normal rip. Yet for others such as "Onii-chan... (Remix)" are formatted in a album track format. Do you think we should change them to all be album track formats or rip format?

If I understand correctly, the "Rock My Forum" meme is supposed to be a "two-for-one" between Ray William Johnson-related sources and "Rock My Emotions", but I noticed that there are currently much more rips in the former category than the latter (specifically, there are about 20 rips that feature "Rock My Emotions" out of the approximately 90 "Rock My Forum" rips).

Additionally, many RWJ sources in the category are rather far removed from "Rock My Forum" itself, such as "Doin Your Mom" or Your Favorite Martian. However, it doesn't feel quite right removing these from the category altogether, as they are somewhat numerous, especially "Doin Your Mom".

A solution I came up with was to just make the meme about Ray William Johnson. I feel like he has a much greater focus on the channel than "Rock My Emotions" and it makes the inclusion of non-Equals Three sources in the category feel more reasonable.

Here's a list template I made if we went through with this change: User:ZachHasArrived/Rips featuring Ray William Johnson

One question I do have is if "Rock My Emotions" should still be counted in this category if the change does happen. I have it listed under "Rock My Forum" in the list above, but it technically doesn't have anything to do with RWJ other than inspiring "Rock My Forum". The only reason I consider this is because of its amount of use, while not high enough to be a meme on its own.

Let me know what you think.

In my opinion, joke pages are pretty funny, so I wanted to discuss adding/editing more of them, but wanted to discuss it first just in case. Here is what I currently have in mind:

• Add a regular version of all of them (that would need it) at the bottom: Currently, with all of the pages in Japanese, there is a section at the bottom that says "English Translation" which has just that, and while most of them are in English, pages like "Snowball Park - Super Mario 3D World" are really hard to understand even being in English, so we should fit them to the regular SiIvaGunner Wiki template.

• Turn both of the Yoda Stories rips into Yoda talk: The Yoda Stories category page is already written in Yoda talk, so why not turn the rip pages into Yoda talk also.

• Turn the rips uploaded during Talk Like a Pirate Day into pirate talk: The Talk Like a Pirate Day page already is written in pirate talk, so why not turn the rip pages into pirate talk also.

What counts as a rip of or featuring a track? Why does a song suddenly become a rip of the track when it is convenient for a freqrip category?

General rips:

• Renai Circulation - Bakemonogatari Portable - was treated as rip featuring Renai Circulation until this very post was made.

The track does not exist in the advertised game.

• Green Hill Zone - Super Smash Bros. Melee - treated as a rip of Green Hill Zone.

The track does not exist in the advertised game.

(The above also tie into the “nonexistent track” idea I had a few months back. It would be an easy way to track them).

KFAD rips:

• Harlem Shake - treated as a rip featuring Harlem Shake.

• CAVE STORY - treated as a rip of Cave Story (Theme Song).

• Gorilla - treated as a rip referencing “Gorilla” by Bruno Mars.

I’m pretty sure the current consensus for rips of tracks is that we link to them from relevant sections on the LOSFIR:

So… what do we do with these? It should be consistent, so whichever option is chosen should be done for all of them.

• They are all rips featuring / referencing?

They will all be removed from the freqriptrack categories, and must instead be moved to respective “rips featuring” and “list of songs featured” pages.

• They are all rips of?

All rior mentions of the tracks on categories/SFIR will need to be changed to “for rips of the track, see the category”. All relevant navboxes will need to be added to the KFAD categories, like with SSBU.

I don’t really like either of these options, but one must be done for consistency. Which of the ideas I presented do you prefer? Is there a third option I haven’t considered?

Figured I'd ask the same question here to get the opinions of those who aren't on Discord.

When counting the number of tracks a frequently ripped track has, should we include the counts of its subcategories?

As an example, "Ground Theme" (Super Mario Bros.) currently has two subcategories: "Game Start" (Super Mario 64) and "Secret Course" (Super Mario Sunshine).

There are currently 46 "Ground Theme" rips, 10 "Game Start" rips, and 19 "Secret Course" rips.

Should the total count for "Ground Theme" on the frequently ripped page be 46 (excluding "Game Start" and "Secret Course") or 75 (46 + 10 + 19)?

Currently, the page shows the total count as 67 (46 "Ground Theme" rips + 19 "Secret Course" rips + 2 categories).

My preference is to not include subcategories in the count (so 46 in the above example), but I'd like to hear as many opinions as possible before making this change.

Tried to find as many rips as I could featuring Yoko's music as a joke and, ended up with over 100 rips.

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLdzv2_dsnXO8RxczHVJmePgFSfW4BqwDk

She also has had two albums dedicated to just her music and was featured in the Art Collab. That might be notable enough to warrant this, my only worry is it possibly being seen as too much of a "generalized" category. Also there's a question about if specifically versions of songs she arranged should be included, which I believe would just remove 4-5 songs from this playlist.

Event names are the title given to celebrations in the SiIvagunner channel. However, some events tend to be referenced with the name of the holiday they appear to happen and not what they're actually celebrating, example: April Fools' Day 2022, it is titled as "April Fools'" but in reality it is about the birthday of Logan Paul.

I personally think this is done for the events to be easily organized, although there are a few exceptions like Adolf Hitler's Birthday and Family Guy Event, they happened during 4/20 but instead they are titled after what they are actually about.

And this is when my problem starts: the wiki does not agrees over how events should be called.

What are your top 5 favorite and top 5 least favorite memes on the channel? I’m curious.

On the List of songs featured in rips/0–E page, in the category rips featured music by Bobby Vinton. The rip "Scar Doesn't Disappear - Yume Nikki" has the old name and no mention of the rip "Lonely Rolling Star (Alpha Version) - Katamari Damacy" where Mr. Lonely. A song by Bobby Vinton is used.

And on the List of songs featured in rips/k-o page, in the category rips featured music by Owl City. A rip using the song When Can I See You Again is not showing. I don't remember the name of the rip in question.

This is all the outdated pages I found.

Jack Black Defines Octagon and Tenacious D have sort of been minor jokes used throughout the channel's history, and I think it would be fine grouping and documenting the two under one category and page.

There are about ~30 rips in the Jack Black Defines Octagon section of the Sesame Street list, and the Spongebob Edited category had about ~60 pages, making the amount of appearances of Jack Black sources around ~90, which seems like a frequent enough amount to become a meme.

Thoughts?

Takakne Shijou from THE iDOLM@STER should get her own page due to her commonly representing “Kyun! Vampire Girl” in the same way Haruka Amami represents “GO MY WAY!!” and Monika represents Doki Doki Literature Club!. She was featured as a character in both the 2019 Halloween Spooktacular Event video series and Curse of the Fallen Angel and more so yeah.

• The category's name isn't accurate if rips sampling them aren't included

• Articles with viewing warnings contains most rips in the category

• Is another random undiscussed category made in 2018

In terms of artwork, playlists, and that kind of stuff, when submitting a rip for a game that doesn't already exist, do you create your own image and keep the playlist blank, or what?

The names of the "rips featuring" categories for this handful of memes are inconsistent with their titles and just annoy me, they should be changed.

Format:

• [Meme title]

• [Category title] (-"Rips featuring ")

[Personal suggestions for change]

• Eggnog

• Life Jacket Kid

• Hate not the Wind, Spring Blossoms ~ Eternal Wind

• Hate Not The Wind, Spring Blossoms ~ Eternal Wind

• Here Comes Pacman

• Pac-Man on Crack

The category name is funny but the official video's title is "Here Comes Pacman".

• John Cena

• The Time Is Now

"The Time Is Now" is not really notable on its own, but broadening what can be included in the category to "Rips featuring John Cena" might make it better

• Let's Do This

• Home Depot

• Love Live!

• Love Live

Wikipedia keeps the exclamation point, the category probably should

• Mr. Krabs

• Mr Krabs

Wikipedia keeps the period, the category probably should

• My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic

• My Little Pony

Change this to the latter, the category refers to the entire franchise but the page only refers to one series in it

• Scatman John

• Scatman

His full performing name is Scatman John, change the category.

• The Love Plug

• Love Plug

• Touhou Project

• Touhou

• U.N. Owen Was Her?

• U.N. Owen was Her?

What is the standart for pages that are melody changes? "The melody has been changed to" or "The melody changes"?

Does anybody know why there’s a bunch of hamood habibi rips today?

August 3rd, 2017 was the 11th anniversary of Rhythm Tengoku, so several rips uploaded were from the Rhythm Heaven series. Should there be a page for it?